In the film, only dumbledore restores the house, sending everything back together with a single wave of his wand. In the deathly hallows book, harry uses the elder wand to mend his own broken wand, and then plans to return the wand to dumbledores tomb. Visual from the movie of the same title warner bros 2005. Only after the attack at the world cup does harry write sirius after hermione tells him he should.
Why is albus dumbledore of the harry potter movies so different. And im discussing th question and answer in the harry potter club. Dumbledore and grindelwald the greater good crimes of. So out of anger, i shat this out in half an hour while baking cookies xddd. We dont get to see voldemorts family history, in which we learn that voldemorts mother gives his muggle. Decades before the legendary duel, gellert grindelwald had come to godrics hollow to stay with his great aunt, bathilda bagshot. Harry looked up at him and saw a tear trickling down dumbledores face into his long silver beard. Who had the upper hand in the duel at the ministry of. Completely killed what dumbledore was supposed to be in the book. After the second movie, hermiones hair was curly at best and straightwavy for the rest of the films. Harry potter is one of the most wildly successful franchises in existence. Sirius black has a prison tattoo in the movies that did not exist in the books.
Another difference from the book is in harrys time in the notquitedeath limbo space with dumbledore. It wouldnt been really tough to portray the book version for those whove never read the book. Movie questions here at magiquiz, youll find the most entertaining quizzes on the internet. For most of the series, he is the headmaster of the wizarding school hogwarts. Differences between characters in the books vs movies. The reason is that the movie ignored a few side stories from the book, none more significant than that of albus dumbledore. Dumbledore shows harry a series of memories in order to prepare him for his quest to destroy the horcruxes, but the movie only shows a few of these. Albus percival wulfric brian dumbledore is a fictional character in j. This trio comprised the elder wand, the resurrection stone, and. It made rowling a household name and paved the way for her to become the first billionaire author. Seeing hagrid give this enlightening news to harry brings delight to the common viewer, who has seen harry bullied by. One fan posted a theory to imgur, pointing out that j. In the book, snape gives harry his memories with his wand as is the norm.
Quizzes books only true harry potter fans can answer these book vs. Study guide comparing and contrasting matilda the book vs. Dumbledore does not pretend as though he had no idea what happened when hermione and harry return from the timeturner trip in. Differences between harry potter and the half blood prince. Harrys first crush came with an abundance of teen angst. Hey guys, in this video we break down the appearance of dumbledore in the filmsmovies and compare it to the way that he was described in. Its time to talk about how the recast dumbledore was. Rowling took the world by storm when she published the first harry potter book, the philosophers stone, way back in 1997. The story of the boy who lived captivated millions, first as a book series and then later over the course of eight films. Her teeth, which was her defining trait besides her hair until the 4th book, was a great. Also, i think with snape shushing harry in the movie, it has a greater impact when snape kills dumbledore, because even though harrys always dealt with his distrust of snape, he trusted him enough to not intervene, believing snape would save dumbledore. Rowling hinted at dumbledores death in the prisoner of azkaban the third book in the franchise years before he was killed off.
In the book, slughorn and dumbledore stand backtoback, waving their wands to restore the house. Its where your interests connect you with your people. The movie needed different editing i think they need to bring in a different director at this point. I feel like in almost every book dumbledore uses at some point whereas in the movie it seemed kind of pointless when it was given to ron. I am sure my support on this question will suffer because of it though. Rowling, called harry potter and the sorcerers stone. Tumblr is a place to express yourself, discover yourself, and bond over the stuff you love. Movie dumbledore for fans of albus dumbledore 14172947. Harry is in prime condition and has access to all feats in movies and books, including harry potter and the cursed child. Also not sure how i felt about those end revelations. He became friends with the seventeen year old albus dumbledore, and they both became obsessed with the powerful objects known as the deathly hallows. In all the potter movie excitement, its important to go back to our hp roots and compare the first real gamechanging harry potter book, harry potter and the goblet of fire, to its movie counterpart.
Harry writes to sirius about his nightmare and scar pain after he first experienced it at the dursleys. In the goblet of fire, when dumbledore asks harry if he put his name into the. Did you put your name in the goblet of fire book dumbledore vs. However, it is apparently also possible to do so in the form of a tear as it was shown in the film, where harry scooped it up in a phial handed to him by hermione, as opposed to the book, where she conjures it from thin air. Narcissa malfoy asks snape to swear the unbreakable vow. Only a true potterhead will get 2020 on this books and. Albus dumbledore quotes 10 best dumbledore quotes paste. And i cant help wish dumbledores story had been told in book format or at least differently.
Can you answer these harry potter book vs movie questions. One of the biggest, of course, was the mention of albus dumbledore, who we now know was newt scamanders professor while at. In the movie, dumbledore explains less and leaves more mystery. Press the keys to navigate the gallery, g to view the gallery, or r to view a random image. In the books, molly weasley had a locket with each of her childrens faces that she wore at all times. But she did act astonished at the idea that everybody hadnt already realised that dumbledore was gay as if she hadnt put in considerable time not writing him gay, while simultaneously writing multiple side characters as explicitly straight. In the books, there is a much larger focus on harry learning about voldemorts past. And the directors made changes based on the huge difference in mediums. In the book, slughorn tells dumbledore that he took a long time in the bathroom, and asks if it were from an upset stomach.
Possessing a great intellectual capacity, matilda teaches herself to solve difficult computations and read novels all by the age of 4 12. Okay, so im writing a paper on harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban right. Book dumbledore vs movie by soupandleaves on deviantart. Even with small changes to the story, this one is perhaps the movie with the least differences from the book. Rowling, harry potter and the order of the phoenix he was also a jolly jokester who had. The movies dumbledore is only related to the books dumbledore by name.
The crimes of grindelwald, a prequel to rowlings bestselling harry potter books, will follow the boy wizards future headmaster albus dumbledore played by jude law as he pursues a. Director mike newell the first british director in the series, did a very good job. In the books, its explicitly stated that dumbledore asked this question calmly. Book hermione vs movie hermione and book dumbledore vs. If you were to read this book and watch the movie you would find many differences, but the main difference between the two is that the book gives more information to the reader than the movie gives to the. Books i hate the notion that dumbledore was somehow distract. Jk rowling revealed that dumbledore was gay in 2007. He looks like dumbledore, and i could imagine dumbledore in the books being irish. Movies correct me if im wrong, but the movies really downplayed dumbledore s deluminator didnt they. In the movie the dursleys are still part of harrys life. In the book, dumbledore goes on to explain how kreacher tricked harry and how snape was the one who alerted the order when harry never. Published in 1988, matilda is the story of a precocious little girl of the same name who lives at home with her brother and selfabsorbed parents who find matilda to be nothing more than a snotty nuisance. Harry potter and the order of phoenix has a lot a lot a lot of differences between the movie and the book as the books grew larger and the movies were still under 3 hours, a lot of compromises were done and a lot of stories were shaved off. In the book, harrys eyes are green while in the movie they are blue.
Book hermione vs movie hermione and book dumbledore vs movie dumbledore. In the movie deathly hallows part two, harry breaks. In all the pottermovie excitement, its important to go back to our hp roots and compare the first real gamechanging harry potter book, harry potter and. Duel between albus dumbledore and gellert grindelwald. As part of his backstory, it is revealed that he is the founder and leader of the order of the phoenix, an organisation dedicated to fighting lord voldemort, the chief antagonist of the series. Im sure most would assume the character differences are due to the fact that michael gambon notoriously didnt read any of the books before taking on the role. In the films, things get a little more intense, and its not totally clear. Dumbledore goes to privet drive to pick him up before the start of school. Although in the book, dumbledore appears calmer than in the movie. List of differences between the harry potter books and. Movie starting with harry potter and the sorcerers stone, we start out with harry potter growing up and learning he is actually a wizard.
While most fans appreciate the books and the movies for their respective merits, there are plenty of book fans who think the movies did a fairly poor job of representing the intricacy and beauty of. Although michael gambon is a fantastic actor, his portrayal of the character wasnt quite true to the book. The best albus dumbledore quotes from the harry potter series reveal the headmasters wisdom and humor. In examining dumbledores character in the books, we find that. The crimes of grindelwald featurette diving into the relationship between albus dumbledore. Set almost a hundred years before the sorcerers stone, it is the end of a friendship, the beginnings of the dark wizard grindelwald, and the tragedy that left the dumbledore family in ruins.1315 369 1308 161 831 177 1205 1278 879 1459 498 543 998 861 922 1386 452 1248 85 1278 1018 948 759 260 452 556 488 169 1576 602 1459 178 26 715 1446 1466 831 1303 541 787 26 37